Best Pacifier for Breastfed Baby

In case you didn’t know, a pacifier (also called a soother, artificial nipple or binky) is a material that is given to a baby to latch on to. While made of rubber, plastic or silicone, an artificial nipple is shaped like a human nipple with a larger shield to keep it from falling out. As a new mother, one way to prevent SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome) is to use a soother for your breastfed baby.

SIDS is a fatal disease that is common in babies who are less than a year old and often occurs when the baby is sleeping. Therefore, using a soother is enough to keep the baby at a distance. Since you already know the importance of a soother, you may be asking yourself, “Which one is best for my baby?

Curiously, no one has an answer to this question, as your newborn baby will ultimately be the ultimate decision-maker. That’s simply because he or she needs to be comfortable with the choice you will ultimately make for him or her. That means he may reject some of them. There are many products on the market that claim to give you value for your money.

The fact is that this is not always the case, because some of them have failed when they were needed most. The good thing is that in this guide we have put together the top seven products from which you can choose. Make no mistake, these are proven products. So, you should make your choice.

How Did We Pick the Best Pacifier for Breastfed Baby?

The main aim of our articles is to make the buying process for our customers as simple, comfortable and effective as possible.

Every review we create is the result of an intricate study of the market, and customer feedback analysis. You’ll always get an honest final verdict. Only after endless hours of research, and once we’re satisfied that we’ve found the best products, do we then add them to our review list for your consideration.

We hope that you enjoy your purchase. If you found this article useful — please share it with your friends. Follow us on social media to stay up to date with more of the best online product reviews.

Best Overall

Nanobebe Pacifiers 0-3 Month - Orthodontic, Curves Comfortably with Face Contour

Key Features

Why It is Better?

Why Do You Need a Pacifier for Breastfed Baby?

Have you bought the best pacifier for breast-fed baby? If not, we’ll explain why you need to give your baby one now! Let’s go!

Supports breastfeeding: While many mothers like to breastfeed their babies, it can also cause discomfort and pain in the nipples and areolas. Indeed, some mothers get cramps when they breastfeed their babies. Pain is pain, it is not pain if your nipple is the cause.

Most often, the pain lasts between 30 and 60 seconds when the baby latches on as much as he or she can. Pain can also be felt around the uterus when the milk starts to flow. If it is not controlled, the uterus may start to shrink. However, nipples help tens of thousands of moms rest while they care for the baby with them. This phenomenon is more pronounced in premature babies.

Saving time: Have you ever imagined how new college moms feel? Although they love having their own baby now, they rarely have time to do anything else. They’re always around the baby, especially if they can’t afford to hire a nanny. If she doesn’t breastfeed the baby, she may have to play with him all the time because there is no one to take care of him. This means that the mother rarely has time for school.

And if this is not checked, it could lead to poor grades. In general, mothers find it very difficult to concentrate when they just go to bed. But a lollipop is a small object that does the job. So it keeps the child occupied while the mother does other things such as reading, cooking, working at home, etc. In short, it provides a temporary distraction.

Exposure to harm: Of course, the artificial nipple can keep the baby occupied for a long time so that the baby has the sensation of playing with the mother’s nipples. You see, babies have a natural tendency to grab or suck on objects – you can call it a sucking reflex. This means that the nipples are not only available for them to latch on, but also that the little ones are no longer exposed to danger.

There have been many reports of babies getting sick and having to be operated on by surgeons. Eventually, they discovered that the babies had swallowed many foreign bodies. These harmful objects caused discomfort. But then lollipops would stick to the babies’ mouths, making it impossible for them to swallow.

Lowers the risk of SIDS: As mentioned earlier, soothers can reduce the risk of your baby suffering from Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). Although there has not been enough evidence to support this claim, medical experts seem to agree that when babies use soothers to sleep, the risk of SIDS is significantly reduced.

Well, recent studies have emerged indicating that it is capable of reducing SIDS by 90%. De-Kun Li, an epidemiology researcher based in California, pointed out that a baby who sleeps on his stomach without a pacifier is 2.5 times more likely to suffer from SIDS. The reproductive epidemiologist pointed out that the risk disappears completely if the child sleeps with a pacifier.

Makes babies to be relaxed: Craving is a behavior that no one can wish for in human beings. From adults to newborns, everyone has something they regularly desire. Apart from looking for food (breast milk), which is very normal for every human being, babies also crave doll-like toys. Often they cry their eyes out if this demand is not met.

Each time they are given some, they are relieved and stop crying. Artificial nipples play an essential role in relieving them when they start crying. Technically, a binky will help the baby fall asleep and sleep well. Similarly, the baby will relax properly with it if you take a flight with it. Overall, this improves their well-being.

Pain relieve: You probably don’t know that when you give your child pacifiers, they help relieve their pain, do you? Well, they do. From lumbar puncture to catheter insertion to immunization, a pacifier works its magic. Although experts have not been able to prove how it works, there is a consensus that pacifiers tend to relieve the pain associated with these conditions. Health experts believe that simulated sucking reflexes relieve pain in several ways. Therefore, they recommend that infants be given pacifiers before undergoing invasive medical procedures.

How to Pick Right Pacifier for a Breastfed Baby

Just before we selected the best pacifiers for newborns, we conducted extensive research. The objective was simply to select the best pacifiers on the market. During the selection of the most effective ones, we used certain criteria. In this segment, we will address them one after the other.

  • Age: This is the most important factor you take into account when choosing the right soother for your baby. We have already discussed the right time to start using a soother. The fact is that if you start using a soother at the wrong time, there are risks involved. As a rule of thumb, you should check the recommended age for your favorite soother. If you want to use the soother for an older baby, there are soothers that are designed for babies between 3 and 6 months of age. If you take your child’s age into account, you can avoid some side effects.
  • Pacifier nipple: You may think that all pacifiers have the same teat shape. Nothing could be further from the truth. In general, there are two different types of pacifiers: They’re natural pacifiers and orthodontic pacifiers. With an orthodontic pacifier, you will help your child’s oral development. Babies, on the other hand, prefer natural pacifiers, and they are much easier to care for. Most of the time, they have only one piece.
  • Price: If you look through the price list for soothers, you’ll see that prices vary. Also, if you have a budget, you should choose the one you can afford. Like everything else, expensive products offer much better value than cheap ones. The more expensive products are more likely to last longer. Although the more expensive ones last longer, you will need to replace nipples from time to time.
  • Size: Another factor to consider is the size of the lollipop. Yes, lollipops are sold at different prices. And yes, sizes are important. You know, there are the small sizes (for 6 months or less), the medium sizes (7 to 18 months) and then the large sizes (for children over 18 years old). The material and shape will determine the size of the pacifier. Most importantly, you should always choose a soother that fits your child perfectly. The fact is that it may make him or her uncomfortable if the soother is too big or too small for your baby. Sometimes a soother that doesn’t fit your child perfectly can cause choking.
  • Material: You must have noticed by now that most soothers are made of silicone. However, it doesn’t stop there. Some artificial teats are also made of latex. Yes, you have read correctly. In fact, latex is softer than silicone. You may be surprised to learn that many babies prefer latex teats to silicone ones. But the disadvantage is that latex materials tend to wear out easily. On the other hand, silicone teats are much cleaner than latex teats.
  • Design: The way a pacifier is designed should matter to you. You already know that they come in 3 different sizes. Keep in mind that if your child’s pacifier falls apart inadvertently, it can lead to a choking hazard. Some types of cups have several pieces, you need to test them separately to make sure the nipple does not come off easily. If it does, there is a good chance that your child may be able to remove it too. One thing to remember is that single nipples are much safer than multiple nipples. Finally, there are plastic pacifiers. Although they are easy to clean, the disadvantage is that many babies tend to turn them over easily.
  • Brands: Although some people don’t pay attention to the brand of a soother, we always advise you to consider that too. The reason for this is that there are popular brands that meet all regulatory requirements. This means that your baby can use them safely. In fact, we don’t need to remind you how important it is to always put your child’s safety first. That being said, you should consider brands such as NUK, Nanobebe, MAM, Itzy Ritzy, Tommee Tippee, Chicco PhysioForma, etc. In fact, all of the products we have reviewed in this guide meet the regulatory requirements. That’s part of the reason they were listed.

Top 7 Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Baby

1. Nanobebe Pacifiers 0-3 Month – Orthodontic, Curves Comfortably with Face Contour Review

Our Rating
4.5/5

Durability

0%

Softness

0%

Ease of Use

0%

Key Features

We Like

We Don’t Like

Here’s an artificial pacifier that will keep your adorable baby safe and active while you concentrate on other activities that are important to you. It is perfectly designed to take the shape of a mom’s nipple, making it our favorite product that gives you the best value for money. As a normal mum or dad, you’ll also appreciate the fact that caring for this soother is not a difficult task. You deserve peace of mind after buying a soother for your child, and this product does that magic.

However, it is not a choking hazard and your baby will not be exposed to harmful chemicals as it does not contain BPA or phthalates. If you need to worry about your baby’s gums and teeth, remember that it was designed with his teeth in mind. If you’re looking for a binky to keep your baby busy, why bother with household chores, that’s just it! Yes, it’s designed to help your newborn baby relax and fall asleep faster than you can imagine.

Public Review Summary

It's the perfect size for newborns and is made of soft, easy-to-clean silicone. But be aware that its size is good enough for newborns, but you'll need to look for a larger one later. This pacifier has a nice design and a variety of colors to choose from. Plus, it's all in one piece, so you don't have to worry about shocks. And sometimes, after boiling it to disinfect it, it can give off a bad smell.

Our Rating
4.5/5

2. NUK Sensitive Orthodontic Pacifiers, 0-6 Months Review

Our Rating
4.6/5

Durability

0%

Softness

0%

Ease of Use

0%

Key Features

We Like

We Don’t Like

With this breasted baby pacifier, you can now offer your baby a product that will relax him or her all day long under your watchful eye. While your baby is sucking on the artificial nipple, you can concentrate on other things that are important to you, such as household chores. It’s even interesting to note that this product is made of 100% silicone, which makes it safe for your child. We consider it to be the best bonus because it is of very high quality, durable and pleasant to use.

That being said, we strongly recommend that you disinfect it with hot water for about 5 minutes before letting your baby suckle it. You will also appreciate the fact that this product has a shield that will not allow your baby to swallow it. Yes, that’s a plus! Once again, the contours are perfectly designed so that it fits your baby’s mouth, giving him the sensation of a mother’s breast. This doesn’t stop your baby from breathing – so you don’t have to worry about it.

Public Review Summary

This pacifier is durable and very easy to clean. It's made of soft silicone, so even if it falls out while your baby is sleeping, this soother won't hurt your baby. You also don't have to worry about water getting into the nipple. But some customers admit that the cut-out in the nose is so low and baby's upper lip may overflow. They also admit that there is often a problem with the size of the pacifier before you buy it.

Our Rating
4.6/5

3. Chicco PhysioForma 100% Soft Silicone One Piece Pacifier for Babies 0-6 Months Review

Our Rating
4.4/5

Durability

0%

Softness

0%

Ease of Use

0%

Key Features

We Like

We Don’t Like

As a new mom, you’re probably struggling with breastfeeding your newborn because of the nipple cramps associated with it. Well, this is one of the best pacifiers for breastfeeding. It is safe to use and meets all the necessary regulatory requirements. Of course, it’s also safe because it contains no BPA or latex – just 100% silicone. You won’t have any trouble attaching it to your baby’s mouth as it has tiny ridges and tends to take the shape of a mummy’s nipple. Plus, you can use it as many times as you like – just sterilize it before using it again.

Worried it might affect your baby’s breathing? You have absolutely no reason to worry because it is designed with user comfort and breathing capacity in mind. Its satin texture helps it stay stuck to your baby’s mouth for as long as he needs it. Its narrow base makes it very easy for your baby to close his lips and promotes the development of his teeth and palate. 

Public Review Summary

The advantage of the Chicco teat is that it has a large handle which is comfortable to use. It is also made of silicone and helps your baby's teeth to return to their natural position. In addition, it comes with a plastic case that can help the teat stay clean when used outdoors. On the other hand, the soother may discolor after boiling and give off a bad smell.

Our Rating
4.4/5

4. MAM Air Pacifiers (2 pack), MAM Sensitive Skin Pacifier 6+ Months Review

Our Rating
4.4/5

Durability

0%

Softness

0%

Ease of Use

0%

Key Features

We Like

We Don’t Like

There is no denying that breastfeeding can be painful, sometimes. But then, this is one of the best pacifiers for breastfeeding. If you have a little boy from 0 to 6 months old who is breastfed, this is the perfect nipple for him. This ensures that you can rest while your baby plays in the house. Since it is 100% silicone (BPA, BPS and lead-free), you don’t have to worry about the safety of the material. Yes, it meets the regulatory standards of the American Academy of Pediatric Guidelines and the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission.

Again, you have absolutely nothing to worry about. You’re probably wondering if it’s good for your little boy because he has exceptionally delicate skin. Guess what, these unique characteristics were taken into consideration before designing this pacifier. Did you know that the pacifier in this pacifier promotes the development of the jaw and teeth? Yes, she does. You don’t have to fight to maintain it as well.

Public Review Summary

It's ideal for children with very sensitive skin or even eczema and helps babies' skin to breathe. Pacifiers are very cute, durable and allow the baby to breathe while sucking on them. They are easy to clean, but it is sometimes difficult to remove the water. And the size of the pacifier is not suitable for all babies, so be careful when choosing one.

Our Rating
4.4/5

5. Evenflo Feeding Balance Plus Stage 1 Cylindrical Baby Pacifier Review

Our Rating
4.6/5

Durability

0%

Softness

0%

Ease of Use

0%

Key Features

We Like

We Don’t Like

If you are looking for a nipple without fatigue, we have one for you. Indeed, the material is so soft and beautiful that it reduces fatigue for newborns and makes it a delight for babies. It’s also on our list because it has most of the qualities you usually look for in your ideal teat. For example, it’s economical, making it one of the most sought-after nipples for parents on a budget. It reduces the risk of SIDS and is easy for newborns to fall in love with. There is no doubt that the design of this product has taken into account the ability to suck healthily during conception.

More importantly, it meets many regulatory requirements, which clearly indicates that it is safe for your baby. For example, it is made of FDA approved food grade material. As a mother looking for one of the best baby pacifiers on the market, you should try this product, as it is designed to take care of your baby while you have plenty of time for yourself.

Public Review Summary

Evenflo soothers are very soft and comfortable to use. They are also made of BPA-free silicone and have holes for breathing. They are easy to clean and what's cool is that you will receive a packet that you can use to steam clean the soothers in the microwave. But as always, there's the other side of the coin, these soothers are big enough for newborns and in some cases may lose their color after cleaning.

Our Rating
4.6/5

6. Tommee Tippee Closer To Nature Soother Day Time Pacifier Review

Our Rating
4.4/5

Durability

0%

Softness

0%

Ease of Use

0%

Key Features

We Like

We Don’t Like

Here comes one of the best baby pacifiers on the market because it makes it so much easier for babysitters. It is a product of Tommee Tippee, an award-winning company that produces baby pacifiers and is very popular for making pacifiers. Although it sounds expensive, you should know that you get 4 different nipples when you place an order for this product. It is made in such a way that any parent can easily care for it.

Although it can last a long time, it is advisable to replace it after a month for health and safety reasons. You should also throw it away if you notice any damage to it. Your baby will enjoy using it because it will have a natural feel. In addition, it contains no harmful chemicals and helps your baby’s teeth, gums and palate to develop. Thanks to its natural shape and feel, your baby will have no difficulty making the transition from nipple to breast to bottle. Without a doubt, all this makes it much easier for parents.

Public Review Summary

There's space to attach the pacifier clip, which is necessary when babies grow when you're on the go. And the great thing about this one is that the baby can hang on to it! While the others immediately come out of the mouth and land on the floor, or out of reach, this one can put his little hand in and continue his little one on his way. But sometimes it's not of the same quality as what's expected of it, so when you disinfect it, be careful.

Our Rating
4.4/5

7. Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother Pacifier Set of 2 – Silicone Newborn Pacifiers Review

Our Rating
4.7/5

Durability

0%

Softness

0%

Ease of Use

0%

Key Features

We Like

We Don’t Like

Do you still need the best pacifier for breastfed baby? If so, you should try this product. As a busy mom, you’ll fall in love with this artificial pacifier because it’s colorful (cute) and easy to clean. Most importantly, your baby will have no trouble holding it firmly and putting it in her mouth because it is very pleasant to the touch. You’ll also like the fact that there are many different models. This means that a mix of different colors and styles makes it one of the most sought-after soothers.

Guess what, it’s very rare for premature babies to latch on to a soother. But there are countless testimonials that say that many of them love it – it’s incredible! Because it comes in so many different colors, it remains the most beautiful soothers on the market. The truth is that children love colorful pacifiers, not yours? Of course, this product offers the perfect color mixes they need to keep them busy while mom and dad take care of other things that matter.

Public Review Summary

It's very well designed and looks very cute. Baby can take a lollipop by himself and put it in his mouth. It's also a good thing, even after months of use, to stay as good as new. The silicone is soft and of excellent quality. The only bad thing people write about this product is that after cleaning it can have a bad smell.

Our Rating
4.7/5

When to Begin and Stop Using a Pacifier for A Breastfed Baby?

At this point, you probably think we’re missing a very important question: When do we start using a pacifier? This question is undoubtedly very crucial, especially for those who have never tried it. According to experts, some parents try to introduce the pacifier on the first night of breastfeeding because they want to rest. This is not a good practice. You need to establish an accurate feeding schedule before thinking about increasing it with pacifiers.

When the normal intake has been set, you can then switch to the intake. Dr. Karen Breach, a pediatrician in North Carolina, said that on average, two weeks should be enough to establish a defined breastfeeding plan. She said that babies would suck whatever you put in their mouths at that time. However, some children would prefer finger sucking to pacifiers. In any case, just switch to taking it after two weeks.

On the other hand, there are signs that it is time to stop giving soothers to a breastfed baby. Yes, there are signs that show that it is time to stop giving soothers to a breastfed baby. If you look closely at the pacifiers we have talked about in this guide, you will see that most of them are recommended for babies from 0 to 6 months. Do you know why? The reason is simply that experts recommend weaning your baby off a soother after 7 months.

According to the American Academy of Pediatricians (AAP), you should remove the pacifier from the baby’s feeding plan as it may cause an ear infection. The American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) agrees with the thoughts of the above-mentioned pediatricians’ association. Both associations state that you put your child at risk of ear infection if you continue to give a pacifier after 6 months, especially if the child is at risk. On the other hand, most children begin to have an aversion to pacifiers as early as the age of 2 to 4 years.

Disadvantages of Using a Pacifier for a Breastfed Baby

Whether you hate it or love it, the best pacifier for breastfed baby also has a few flaws. We will discuss these drawbacks shortly.

Using a Pacifier Safely

Clean it regularly: You must clean your child’s soother all the time to eliminate germs. Remember that germs are everywhere, and you can’t see them with the naked eye because of their size. So you need to clean your baby’s soother every day to keep germs away. Make sure you wash it with mild dishwater and let it air dry. You can also put it in the dishwasher as it works for some of them.

The advantage is that most of them come with cleaning instructions; follow them. Be sure to sanitize it if necessary. It only takes 5 to 10 minutes for your pacifier to be disinfected. As explained above, you can also steam disinfect them using a microwave. There is always a one-piece, dishwater-resistant silicone model available – you should get started.

Replace them when necessary: To use a pacifier safely, you must be prepared to get rid of it at any time and get a replacement. This is because it is unhealthy as soon as it is damaged. To be able to spot signs of damage, you should inspect it before using it at any time. Watch for cracks around the nipple and shield.

If you find any damage, you should discard the pacifier and replace it. It is not healthy to continue using it after cracks have been found. If there is no damage, medical experts advise users to replace the soother one month after use for safety and hygiene reasons.

Have more than one: Many factors can cause cracks. These include bouncing on the sofa, falling on the floor and many others. When a lollipop experiences one of these factors, it can crack. More often than not, it becomes very difficult to get rid of a pacifier when signs of damage have been spotted because you don’t have a replacement for the existing pacifier.

It is pathetic that some people continue to sterilize and use pacifiers when these cracks have been spotted. This is not a good safety practice. In addition, more and more products are being fitted with clips. If you have to use the clip during the day – never at night when the baby is sleeping.

Don’t coat a pacifier with sugar: You may be tempted to sweeten or sugar-coat a pacifier just to get your baby to like it. This is an act of desperation and should be avoided. Sometimes babies refuse pacifiers. When this happens, keep trying other brands. Many parents have testified that their babies don’t like one brand of pacifier but like another.

Therefore, it is best to try several brands, especially colored brands, because babies like colorful objects. The important thing to remember here is never to dip the soother in sweet liquids, such as food and honey, just to make your baby like it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are the answers to some of the frequently asked questions from (prospective) users:

As a mother, you would have discovered that newborns have sucking reflexes. You should keep in mind that orthodontic soothers are specially designed to support your baby after his or her third birthday. In addition, your baby will appreciate having them on her mouth whenever she wants to sleep or relax. So, yes, you should.

Most parents face the challenge of not knowing how to remove artificial pacifiers. To do this, you need to follow these steps:

  • Set a removal date
  • Also tell them great stories and how crucial it is to stop using binky.
  • You should gradually reduce the frequency of use
  • And you should use something else to replace the pacifier when you’re about to end the era of applying a pacifier to your baby.
  • It has to be progressive and you have to be creative…
  • Finally, you need to build your child’s confidence. Let them know that big boys or girls don’t need lollipops, because they’re only for children. That way you build their self-confidence.

Since this binky meets the regulatory requirements, you can be sure that the MAM clip does not contain any harmful substances. In fact, the entire product range meets the requirements. For example, it complies with OEKO-Tex and other international standards. Of course, you can use it safely.

The answer is simply NO. Although there have been cases where babies have managed to squeeze out the whole soother, there have never been cases where babies have swallowed their soother. If it gets stuck in your child’s mouth, gently remove it by grasping the button. This is how you will be able to remove most of it easily.

Conclusion

In truth, this guide has been instructive. From the introduction to the conclusion, we’ve explained all the critical facts you need to know about pacifiers. To quickly summarize some of the key points, we’ve dissected the pros and cons of pacifiers, the right time to start and finish using it, how to keep a pacifier clean, what to look out for in your ideal product, and some important questions parents ask about pacifiers. In fact, the whole trip was worthwhile.

Most importantly, we’ve reviewed some of the best products on the market for you. You should know that we came to this conclusion after using the criteria we’ve discussed in the guide to conduct extensive research. In other words, we’ve done the work for you! As a parent who has never used a pacifier, all you have to do is choose from our list of 7 best pacifiers for newborns. Do it, and you’ll be absolutely delighted to do so. Place your order now!

When the normal intake has been set, you can then switch to the intake. Dr. Karen Breach, a pediatrician in North Carolina, said that on average, two weeks should be enough to establish a defined breastfeeding plan. She said that babies would suck whatever you put in their mouths at that time. However, some children would prefer finger sucking to pacifiers. In any case, just switch to taking it after two weeks.

On the other hand, there are signs that it is time to stop giving soothers to a breastfed baby. Yes, there are signs that show that it is time to stop giving soothers to a breastfed baby. If you look closely at the pacifiers we have talked about in this guide, you will see that most of them are recommended for babies from 0 to 6 months. Do you know why? The reason is simply that experts recommend weaning your baby off a soother after 7 months.

According to the American Academy of Pediatricians (AAP), you should remove the pacifier from the baby’s feeding plan as it may cause an ear infection. The American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) agrees with the thoughts of the above-mentioned pediatricians’ association. Both associations state that you put your child at risk of ear infection if you continue to give a pacifier after 6 months, especially if the child is at risk. On the other hand, most children begin to have an aversion to pacifiers as early as the age of 2 to 4 years.